Blockchain’s Immutability Could Hold-up in Bankruptcy
Posted by Digital Asset on Jul 11, 2019 7:58:00 PM

 

Blockchain image 2-1

Committed settlement, a patent-pending methodology introduced by  Digital Asset , could present a way to make financial transactions immutable

By Charlie Yeh, Assistant General Counsel, Digital Asset

When Blockchain Immutability Meets Bankruptcy

 

“Immutable” is a term that is frequently used when people talk about blockchain and the benefit of using this technology for record-keeping.

Blockchain is designed to provide an immutable, indelible, unalterable, and untamperable source of truth. Many other benefits associated with blockchain technology, such as, data integrity, security, and transparency are built upon this fundamental quality. The application of this technology to record financial transactions seems like a panacea -- imagine a crowd-sourced golden record of all transactions of value between two or more participants that’s mutual, immutable, indisputable and permanent.

But, the reality is that financial transactions are not immutable. Why? 

Bankruptcy.

In addition to instances where one party may simply intentionally or unintentionally default on a transaction, bankruptcies may create forced defaults on agreed-upon but pending transactions.  Once a party files for bankruptcy or is declared insolvent, a bankruptcy stay prevents most pending transaction from moving forward. Even previously settled transactions may be voidable as a result of bankruptcy and may be clawed back. We witnessed how devastating bankruptcy and default can be on the financial system when Lehman Brothers collapsed in 2008: the current financial system is not immutable.

The havoc created by a bankruptcy judge and the bankruptcy trustee in stopping, unwinding, or clawing back transactions on an immutable blockchain would be even more devastating.

What if We Could Make Financial Transactions Immutable? 

Instead of questioning what happens when an immovable object meets an unstoppable force, what if blockchains and smart contracts were utilized to make transactions bankruptcy remote, using existing bankruptcy laws and safe harbor statutes to structure transactions in ways to protect them from bankruptcy that are not currently feasible or efficient with existing technology?

If this can be done, blockchain can in fact provide an immutable record of financial transactions, and financial transactions could benefit from all of the efficiencies of blockchain.

How? Committed Settlement.

A first step in this process towards true immutability is Committed Settlement, a smart contract method conceived by Digital Asset.

Committed Settlement enables users to replicate control accounts (accounts used for over a century to hold collateral pledged by a pledgor to protect the secured party against a default or bankruptcy of the pledgor), by locking digitized assets to a specific purpose. While control accounts are commonly used to shield pledged collateral from bankruptcy, they are slow (taking several months to set up), costly (thousands of dollars in maintenance fees), and inefficient (placing onerous reporting, reconciliation, and maintenance obligations on all of the parties involved).  

In contrast, by using DAML, an open source programming language created by Digital Asset, Committed Settlement could be accomplished by writing a few lines of code into a smart contract (the digital representation of a physical contract) between counterparties. By using smart contracts, Committed Settlement also utilizes the built in reporting and maintenance routines and avoids reconciliation burdens.

While there are additional steps from control accounts to true bankruptcy protection, this is a large and important first step towards the ability to use blockchain for immutable record-keeping of financial transactions.

Legal Considerations

To substantiate our patent-pending Committed Settlement methodology, we’ve collaborated with trusted law firms to analyze the local legal frameworks in a variety of jurisdictions.  The first of our collaborations is with King & Wood Mallesons, one of the world’s most innovative law firms. The following thought piece looks at whether Digital Asset’s implementation of Committed Settlement would work under the legal framework of Hong Kong and Australia.

Click here to read our thought piece with KWM, Committed Settlement in Hong Kong and Australia.

 
Charlie Yeh is an assistant general counsel at Digital Asset where he helps clients understand how distributed ledger and smart contract technology align with prevailing legal frameworks.  Previously Charlie served as legal counsel to JPMorgan’s prime custody, clearing and collateral management businesses. He helped JPMorgan reduce its trillion dollar intraday exposure to clearing repurchase agreements and establish segregated IM control accounts on behalf of it clients. 
 

 

 

Blockchain image 2-1

Committed settlement, a patent-pending methodology introduced by  Digital Asset , could present a way to make financial transactions immutable

By Charlie Yeh, Assistant General Counsel, Digital Asset

When Blockchain Immutability Meets Bankruptcy

 

“Immutable” is a term that is frequently used when people talk about blockchain and the benefit of using this technology for record-keeping.

Blockchain is designed to provide an immutable, indelible, unalterable, and untamperable source of truth. Many other benefits associated with blockchain technology, such as, data integrity, security, and transparency are built upon this fundamental quality. The application of this technology to record financial transactions seems like a panacea -- imagine a crowd-sourced golden record of all transactions of value between two or more participants that’s mutual, immutable, indisputable and permanent.

But, the reality is that financial transactions are not immutable. Why? 

Bankruptcy.

In addition to instances where one party may simply intentionally or unintentionally default on a transaction, bankruptcies may create forced defaults on agreed-upon but pending transactions.  Once a party files for bankruptcy or is declared insolvent, a bankruptcy stay prevents most pending transaction from moving forward. Even previously settled transactions may be voidable as a result of bankruptcy and may be clawed back. We witnessed how devastating bankruptcy and default can be on the financial system when Lehman Brothers collapsed in 2008: the current financial system is not immutable.

The havoc created by a bankruptcy judge and the bankruptcy trustee in stopping, unwinding, or clawing back transactions on an immutable blockchain would be even more devastating.

What if We Could Make Financial Transactions Immutable? 

Instead of questioning what happens when an immovable object meets an unstoppable force, what if blockchains and smart contracts were utilized to make transactions bankruptcy remote, using existing bankruptcy laws and safe harbor statutes to structure transactions in ways to protect them from bankruptcy that are not currently feasible or efficient with existing technology?

If this can be done, blockchain can in fact provide an immutable record of financial transactions, and financial transactions could benefit from all of the efficiencies of blockchain.

How? Committed Settlement.

A first step in this process towards true immutability is Committed Settlement, a smart contract method conceived by Digital Asset.

Committed Settlement enables users to replicate control accounts (accounts used for over a century to hold collateral pledged by a pledgor to protect the secured party against a default or bankruptcy of the pledgor), by locking digitized assets to a specific purpose. While control accounts are commonly used to shield pledged collateral from bankruptcy, they are slow (taking several months to set up), costly (thousands of dollars in maintenance fees), and inefficient (placing onerous reporting, reconciliation, and maintenance obligations on all of the parties involved).  

In contrast, by using DAML, an open source programming language created by Digital Asset, Committed Settlement could be accomplished by writing a few lines of code into a smart contract (the digital representation of a physical contract) between counterparties. By using smart contracts, Committed Settlement also utilizes the built in reporting and maintenance routines and avoids reconciliation burdens.

While there are additional steps from control accounts to true bankruptcy protection, this is a large and important first step towards the ability to use blockchain for immutable record-keeping of financial transactions.

Legal Considerations

To substantiate our patent-pending Committed Settlement methodology, we’ve collaborated with trusted law firms to analyze the local legal frameworks in a variety of jurisdictions.  The first of our collaborations is with King & Wood Mallesons, one of the world’s most innovative law firms. The following thought piece looks at whether Digital Asset’s implementation of Committed Settlement would work under the legal framework of Hong Kong and Australia.

Click here to read our thought piece with KWM, Committed Settlement in Hong Kong and Australia.

 
Charlie Yeh is an assistant general counsel at Digital Asset where he helps clients understand how distributed ledger and smart contract technology align with prevailing legal frameworks.  Previously Charlie served as legal counsel to JPMorgan’s prime custody, clearing and collateral management businesses. He helped JPMorgan reduce its trillion dollar intraday exposure to clearing repurchase agreements and establish segregated IM control accounts on behalf of it clients. 
 

 

Topics:

Smart Contracts, DAML, DLT, settlement, committed settlement

Recent Posts
NEWS
The Power of DAML and Interoperability in Blockchain
05/22/2020
NEWS
Healthcare Smart Contracts with DAML
05/12/2020
NEWS
Money, Money, Money: The Future of Payments?
04/23/2020
NEWS
Exactpro Enables Testing for DAML-built Applications
04/23/2020
PRESS RELEASE
WeBank to Integrate DAML with China’s Leading Blockchain Platform
04/15/2020
NEWS
Waters Wavelength Podcast: Digital Asset on Blockchain
04/2/2020
NEWS
Bloomberg TV speaks to Yuval Rooz: Transforming Blockchain Markets
04/2/2020
NEWS
Digital Asset Steps Up A Gear In Enterprise Blockchain
03/30/2020
PRESS RELEASE
Digital Asset is First Blockchain Startup to Successfully Complete AICPA Type 2 SOC 2 Examination
03/5/2020
NEWS
Emnet Rios Joins Forbes Finance Council
03/4/2020
PRESS RELEASE
Hyperledger Besu now has DAML Smart Contracts
03/3/2020
PRESS RELEASE
BTP brings smart contracts to Amazon QLDB with Sextant for DAML
02/25/2020
PRESS RELEASE
Leading Tech Companies Join Series C Financing & Former Microsoft Exec Joins Board
02/4/2020
BLOG
Outcompeting Destructive Systems with Smart Contracts
02/3/2020
PRESS RELEASE
Odyssey Introduces Goals of the Odyssey Hackathon 2020 in Davos
01/24/2020
BLOG
Smart Contracts for Social Good: Unlocking Blockchain's Potential Beyond Finance
12/19/2019
PRESS RELEASE
XBourse Global Designs Market Infrastructure of the Future with DAML
12/16/2019
PRESS RELEASE
Digital Asset Raises $35 Million in Series C Financing to Capture Smart Contract Market with DAML
12/11/2019
BLOG
Low-code Smart Contracts for the Enterprise with Unibright and DAML
12/9/2019
PRESS RELEASE
Unibright enables anyone to create DAML smart contracts with “no code” developer tools
11/21/2019
PRESS RELEASE
Digital Asset and Blockchain Technology Partners deliver Sextant for DAML
11/7/2019
NEWS
DAML: the contract language of distributed ledgers
11/6/2019
BLOG
Committed Settlement: Adoption under UK Law, an analysis by Linklaters
09/26/2019
NEWS
Broadridge: Distributed Repo
07/17/2019
BLOG
Blockchain’s Immutability Could Hold-up in Bankruptcy
07/11/2019
BLOG
A Generational Opportunity to Improve the Transfer of Value
05/30/2019
BLOG
Synchronize New York 2019: Digital Asset and DLT in the Real World
05/17/2019
BLOG
DAML Driven Development: Optimis
03/15/2019
BLOG
Change Healthcare Introduces Payment Blockchain Proof-of-Concept at HIMSS ’19
02/7/2019
BLOG
DAML Driven Development: MV37
01/22/2019